This looks like fun!
I live in upstate New York and here's what I can offer for swap from this area:
Dinosaur BBQ sauces (mmm, mmm good)
Different kinds of cooking sauces, oils, etc.
Grandma Brown Baked Beans
REAL maple syrup
Syracuse University stuff
(hats, mugs, pins, school mascot, etc - or something from the School of Art and Design)
Older design magazines
1000 Islands dressing, 1000 Island souvenirs
River Rat cheese
Locally made honey- honey sticks, honey butter
New York state wines (Finger Lakes region)
State Fair Spedie Sauce (for beef or chicken)
Chocolate Covered Potato Chips
Anything else you want? I'll do my best to get it!